Top 5 Best Diaper Pail for cloth diapers (mommas’ reviews)

Sharing is caring! Mamas care!

If you are a first-time mom, a diaper pail for cloth diapers might not be one of the top priorities in your baby registry. However, you will discover that as your baby grows older and the diaper keeps piling up – it might be one of the most needed nursery items in the home.

Pin Image of Diaper Pail For Cloth Diaper

*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links from Amazon or other publishers I trust (at no extra cost to you). See disclosure for details.

So, having the right diaper pail or diaper bin as the case may be will make a big difference not only in the quality of air around the house but also in the quality of your life and that of the little one.

Do I Need A Diaper Pail?

Yes, you need one though some might see it as unnecessary – but if you want to continuously have a good smell in your nursery, then go for it. The diaper pail will help to keep the smell of the diaper trapped inside while the usual ‘trash can’ will permit this odor to get released into the room.

Besides, most of the diaper pails are reusable – this can be made possible by the use of reusable liners and refills in the place of garbage bags. This will help you to avoid wastage in the use of garbage bags to hold your stinky diapers.

Methods Of Cloth Diapers Storage

There are three available methods of cloth diaper storage, these are;

  • Dry pail method
  • Wet pail method
  • A combination of both dry and wet method

Dry Pail Method

This is the most common method among nursing mothers – here, the diapers do need to be pre-soaked as they are stored dry in a reusable waterproof bag. Under the dry method, the diaper pail is lined with a waterproof bag.

So, the waterproof can now be hung either on a doorknob or a hook – this eliminates the use of a pail.

If you make use of a front and top-load washer – then this method is recommended for you because the waterproof bag can be easily dumped into the washer.

Things to note with the dry pail method

It is advised to have two pail liners. Since the used one goes into the washing machine with the dirty diapers, so, the clean one is ready for use.

You must desist from the use of woven material like cotton inlining your diaper pail because it will retain smell and absorb moisture.

Also, a pail liner with elastic around the top is advisable – this will fix it tightly to the can without slipping down inside the cloth diaper making it look like a trash can

Solid poop should be removed from the diaper before dumping into the bag, but this can be overlooked for babies still on breast milk because it can easily be washed off in the washing machine.

Wet Pail Method

Under this arrangement, the diapers are pre-soaked in a container with small water. The water helps to reduce stains, odor, and pre-treat diapers. Besides, additives like washing soda, essential oils, or baking soda can be added to the water.

However, you replace the water daily to eliminate smell and prevent stains. It is best recommended for top-load washers that allow direct dumping of contents into the machine.

Things to note with the wet pail method

Do not use bleach or detergent in the water – could be harsh on the diaper material and it’s capable of voiding the manufacturer’s warranty.

It could be heavy if too full – so, don’t buy a very big wet diaper pail.

With the wet diaper pails, there is a high risk of drowning for children. So, use a waterproof container that can be tightly locked – be sure to seal tightly after every use.

Combination Of Dry And Wet Pail Method

You might want to combine both the wet and dry storage method. It involves rinsing the diaper to remove urine and then store the inserts inside a wet pail while covers are stored inside a dry bag.

What To Consider When Buying A Diaper Pail

*Size of the pail – for smaller pails, regular disposal of dirty diapers is essential while the bigger pails can contain diapers of up to a week or more. Also, the available space in your home will determine the type of pail to buy.

*The type of pail liners (diaper bags) – some pails can accommodate washable cloth bag liners or the usual trash bags. Some will require special liners that come directly from the manufacturers. The cost of these special liners will add up in the long run – so decide on the type of bag and cost implications.

*Ease of access to the pail – you can either open the pail by using a foot pedal or a handle or even a flip lid. So, you want a pail where you can easily dispose of your diapers and without releasing odors into the home.

*Ease of disposing of the diapers – this has to do with disposing the diapers from the pail into the washing machine. So, choose what will make the task easy for you.

*Safety – with wet diaper pails – it must be properly locked at all times to prevent drowning. You must ensure that your baby’s hand cannot reach the pail.

Best Diaper Pail For Cloth Diapers

Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail – Ranked As The Overall Best

Photo of Ubbi Steel Diapr Pail; ranked as the best diaper pail

The Ubbi metal diaper pail has good looks because it’s made from steel – so, it can last through several children.  Also, it is built to contain odor and prevent it from leaking out into the room.

Besides, it is easy to use and comes with a child lock on the lid to prevent your little one from gaining access to it.

Interestingly, you do not need special diaper bags to use this – the common kitchen trash bag or reusable cloth liner can be used with it. 

However, this metal diaper pail is not built with a foot pedal, so you would need a free hand to open the knob on top.

Busch Systems Odorless Cloth Diaper Pail – Best Pail For Cloth Diapers

Photo of Busch Systems Odorless Diaper Pail

It is the best for cloth diapers because it’s built with enough space to contain the diapers. It is made from recycled plastic and it’s also recyclable.

Also, it comes with a carbon filter attached to the lid which makes it hold up to two days of diapers and absorbs all the smells. Also, the carbon filter ensures that air can come in to prevent mold but prevent the smell from escaping.  Besides, it’s lightweight – which makes it easy to be moved around the house.

The Busch systems odorless cloth diaper pail can accommodate both the dry and wet pail method.

Playtex Diaper Genie – Best Odor-Minimizing Diaper Pail

Photo of Playtex Diaper Genie

You might think this is only made for disposable diapers but no – it can work well for cloth diapers as well. Besides, this diaper pail is designed with antimicrobial walls to prevent bacterial growth within the pail.

Here, there is no need of using hands in opening it as it comes with a foot pedal. When you have a challenge with space, the Playtex diaper genie is a good option because it takes little space.

Besides, you will find it easy to use because it is already pre-assembled. However, due to its size, the Playtex Diaper genie can only hold a limited number of diapers and you cannot use it as a wet diaper pail.

Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail – Best Budget-Friendly Diaper Pail

Photo of Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail

It has a larger space that can contain both disposable and cloth diapers. It is designed with a foot pedal which makes it hands-free.

Interestingly, the dekor diaper pail can easily be converted to a trash can when your baby is through with using diapers. Other important safety features that make it stand out include; odor-blocking trap door, a child’s lock, and quiet lid closure.

With the Dekor diaper pail, you need not worry about its set-up as it comes completely assembled.

Having this diaper pail will also require buying a Dekor brand bag which can hold up to 2, 320 diapers – but you do not need to buy this often. Also, it cannot be used for the wet pail method.

Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered By Arm And Hammer – Best Odor Control Dry Pail

Photo of Munchkin Diaper Pail

If you place a premium on odor control, then the Munchkin step diaper pail is the best available option in the market. It comes with a lavender refill that helps to better control the odor.

Also, it is built with a foot pedal making it completely hands-free – this makes it easy to use and reduces germ infection. It is suitable for both disposable and cloth diapers

However, it’s not usable as a wet pail method. It’s narrow opening also makes it a bit difficult to get diapers through. Also, it is slightly heavy (weighing about 12 pounds).

Best Diaper Pail Bags

Some diaper pails might not require liners but some do – liners are of great benefits making them important accessories to diaper pails.

Therefore, the following are the best diaper pail bags available:

Alvababy Reusable Diaper Pail Liner

Photo of Alvababy Diaper Pail Bag

It is waterproof, so it ensures that nothing leaks out of the bag. With the Alvababy diaper pail bag – you can keep up to between 20 to 25 diapers for at least two days. It attaches itself firmly to the diaper pail so there is no need to worry about slipping off.

Besides, it is machine washable and available in different colors.

Teamoy Reusable Pail Liner

Photo of Teamoy Reusable Diaper Pail Liner

This can function independently without the pail. Also, it is waterproof, durable, and can be attached to a doorknob, hook rack, or even towel bar.

It can easily be emptied into the washing machine. Also, it comes in two – of which they are machine washable. Besides, the Teamoy Reusable pail liner comes with an elastic that fits the pail firmly and you might also want to try this product without a diaper pail

However, it cannot contain many diapers when used without a pail, and also the possibilities of leakage are high when used without a pail.


As you go through the journey of childbearing, you will have to handle a ton of diapers – whether cloth diapers or disposable diapers. The diaper pail in your nursery will help you maintain a smell-free home.

So, whether your choice is the overall best diaper pail, or the best for cloth diapers, or the best odor-minimizing diaper pail, or the best budget-friendly diaper pail, or the best odor-control diaper pail – it is a necessity for cloth diapering. It will help to store dirty cloth diapers for days without your home smelling.

Lily & The MBH Team
Latest posts by Lily & The MBH Team (see all)

Sharing is caring! Mamas care!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website.